Ticking Timebomb

You might remember my first significant Peer Review appeal “victory”. I have just seen the written response and despite achieving the desired re-grading I am still uneasy about some of their findings – anyhow time to let go now.
There is one interesting and important comment which stands out to me:

“The fact that this ‘ticklist’ approach may be SQM compliant does not make it acceptable for the purpose of peer review.”

About Author: SP

Comments are closed.